The qualities that initially made you successful as a leader eventually hold you back. That sounds counterintuitive. We tend to think of leadership development as a process to identify weakness and fix it. Become a better communicator. Delegate more. Develop greater emotional intelligence. Improve strategic thinking. But some of the most damaging leadership behaviours begin as strengths.
Leaders don’t just suddenly become bad at leadership. Instead, they become too dependent on one version of themselves or their identity. And that’s a much harder problem to recognise.
Success Shapes Identity
Think about the behaviours that helped you advance in your career. Maybe you are the person everyone turns to when something goes wrong. Or maybe you are willing to make the hard choices. Maybe you are great at motivating people. Those behaviours produced results and shaped your identity.
Psychologists talk about “self-concept” to describe the collection of beliefs that define who we are. Once we see ourselves a certain way, we naturally behave consistently within that identity. For me, I like to solve problems and be the one who fixes things. Over my career, that has led me to take on more than I should. I take pride in my ability to get things done. All of us are drawn to that kind of consistency, because it gives us a stable sense of self. For leaders, however, it can also become a trap.
When A Strength Becomes Something You Have To Protect
Once a leadership behaviour becomes part of your identity, changing that behaviour feels like a threat to who you are. A decisive leader may struggle to say, “I don’t know.” A visionary may have trouble abandoning an idea after the evidence changes. A leader known for solving problems may have trouble delegating.
This is where two characteristics become important: identity-protective cognition and confirmation bias. Pull these together, and you get a perfect storm of leadership danger.
Essentially, we tend to interpret information in ways that protect how we see ourselves. When something challenges an important part of our identity, we’re more likely to question or dismiss it. In most areas of our lives, we pay greater attention to evidence that supports what we already believe. For leaders, success becomes evidence that the behaviour should be repeated.
Every Strength Casts A Shadow
This creates one of the paradoxes of leadership. The difference between a strength and a weakness is often context and degree.
A strength pushed too far can become something else entirely. Conviction can harden into stubbornness, while confidence can drift toward arrogance. A strong sense of accountability can turn into control, just as empathy can lead to avoiding a difficult conversation. Even sacrifice and decisiveness have limits, becoming martyrdom or impulsiveness when taken too far.
The underlying trait hasn’t necessarily changed. What changed is your ability to regulate it. This is why leadership problems can be difficult for successful people to recognise. The behaviour causing the problem may be the same behaviour that produced years of positive reinforcement.
In behavioural psychology, reinforcement increases the likelihood that a behaviour will be repeated. Companies provide leaders with enormous amounts of it: promotions, compensation, praise, and authority. The organisation is effectively saying, “Whatever you’re doing, keep doing it.” So they do.
The Leadership Question We Should Ask
Historically, leadership development begins with a question: What kind of leader are you? It’s a good question, but it inadvertently encourages leaders to search for a fixed identity. A better question may be: What does my team need from me right now? That shift requires psychological flexibility, or the ability to adapt behaviour to circumstances as they change rather than responding automatically.
A leader may need to be decisive during a crisis and collaborative during strategic planning. They may need to challenge the organisation one day and create stability the next. They may need to step up when the team lacks direction and step back when the team needs freedom to get things done. Maturing in leadership isn’t eliminating your natural tendencies. It’s expanding the number of responses available to you.
Find The Behaviour You Can’t Stop Doing
There’s a relatively simple way to begin identifying where your strength may have become an identity trap. Ask yourself this question: What leadership behaviour do I have the hardest time turning off? This shouldn’t be easy. Dig deep. Pay attention to the discomfort, because that discomfort may be signalling something. You may no longer be choosing a leadership behaviour. You may be protecting an identity. And that’s the distinction leaders need to recognise.
Your greatest strength isn’t dangerous because it’s a strength. It becomes dangerous because you rarely have the ability to turn it off. Your goal should be to develop enough self-awareness and psychological flexibility that your identity expands as your responsibilities change. Because eventually, nearly every successful leader faces the same challenge. The person who got you here may not be the person who can take you there. And that’s a leadership problem we can solve.
Follow Tyler on Instagram: @thetylerpearsonofficial or at www.identitybeforeinfluence.com
Enjoyed this article? Add People Development Magazine as a preferred source on Google:
